"Boys in Our Books"…

…we're keeping our name but expanding our offerings!

COVERS WEEK REVIEW: “Discreet Young Gentleman” by MJ Pearson

“(Don’t?) Judge A Book By Its Cover” Week

PersonalizedBannerTracy

Tracy votes THUMBS DOWN on the cover for “Discreet Young Gentleman”. Let’s see how the book itself fared…

ABOUT:

All hell breaks loose when Dean Smith, Earl of Carwick, is tricked into being discovered in the company of Rob, a handsome male prostitute. Now Dean needs to repair his broken engagement to a wealthy heiress…and Rob is the only one who can identify the man who set him up, proving to Dean’s fiancée that things weren’t as they appeared.

The trip from Worcester to Bath turns into a journey of self-discovery, as Dean finds himself becoming increasingly attracted to Rob. His charming companion stirs feelings Dean has long kept repressed, but acting on them would make true the accusations that destroyed his engagement. Torn between duty and desire, Dean’s destiny lies in the hands of a Discreet Young Gentleman.

REVIEW:

This is Covers Week at BIOB, so let’s first get to the cover of the m/m regency romance Discreet Young Gentleman—a cover that I think is pretty awful, especially since it’s using a photo of a model who I can now and forever only think of as Tony from Kaje Harper’s Life Lessons. (Here he is on the cover of book #3, Home Work.)

 

8938290
I do like the pastoral road background behind naked thoughtful Tony though, especially since that represents well the long journey upper-class Dean takes with “hired man” Rob as they travel from Dean’s country estate to Bath to try to regain the favor of the woman Dean was betrothed to (and then hopefully rebuild Dean’s finances so he can keep his family home.)

The REAL crime with this cover though is that it is NOT the earlier, original cover–a painted, chest-heaving dream that should be hung in a museum somewhere, preferably in an exhibit titled “Pulp Pleasures and Pants Missiles: The Wonderful World of Gay Romance Covers.”

I mean LOOK AT THIS. IT IS AWESOME.

 

202749

(Although I love that the front, fondled guy has the coppery hair of Dean, dark-haired fondling guy looks more like a regency Wolverine to me rather than the handsome, lithe Rob.)

(Regency Wolverine…there’s an idea…)

My guess for the cover update to “Naked Tony and the Pastoral Road” is probably something to do with ebook and reprint rights, etc, which is too bad since that earlier pants-poking tryst under the fireglow glory should not be lost in history. There should be a monument somewhere so that Regency Wolverine and his breathless companion can be forever caught in mid-heave, stared at by curious (and quietly aroused) tourists who will then throw pennies at it with the unspoken wish that the Gods of Grasping Lust will bestow on them good fortune and drawn-out glorious orgasms.

Also, the title font is awesome—it’s like someone stole a title card from an 80’s cartoon geared towards girls—like My Little Pony or Jem, and was all, “THIS! This brings the right amount of *DAZZLE* for our story of a stick-in-the-mud Earl and his journey of torment as he tries REALLY REALLY HARD to not fall for the harlot hotness that is his traveling companion.

Okay-okay. What about the story?

I’ve read a few “regency rentboy” stories, and I have to say, this one is nicely different. Dean is still the somewhat tortured high-class character, and Rob is a prostitute trapped with a mindset that he’s good for little else than sex, but beyond that, the story takes a much different turn and tone than others that I’ve read.

It is mostly the journey here that is the focus, as Dean coerces Rob to help him regain his lost honor and his ex-fiancé’s favor, but they find their trip prolonged by mishaps, and then Dean finds himself prolonging it further to provide history-loving Rob a chance to explore some of the sites along the way, including a plethora of haunted inns and abbeys. This time forces Dean to ponder things he really didn’t want to ponder, like how much he enjoys Rob’s company, how he desperately doesn’t want to think of Rob with his “patrons”, and how his life could have been different if he wasn’t in this financial pickle.

Dean was a hard character to like at first—he’s moody and restrained and kind of a pill, but very slowly he thaws under Rob’s sunny, inquisitive demeanor, and just as Rob learns more about the layers underneath Dean’s cool façade, so does the reader, and I warmed more up to him in the last third as he became more fumblingly aware of his mistakes and what he wants.

I was gearing for a lower rating, since the story is drawn-out, mostly UST, and I can only read about Dean’s self-denial for so long, but the ending was nice, and really picked things up for me.

(There is also an interlude story that Rob tells to Dean at one point as he explains why he often sleeps with older men—a story of one of his past lovers, and I won’t lie, it was one of the most romantic things I’ve read in a while.)

If you enjoy m/m historicals, especially the regency variety, then it’s easy for me to recommend this one. It is nicely different, and oddly, it felt more “equal”, even with the characters’ different stations, and Dean’s unhappy judgment of Rob’s profession.

Also, if you like dolls in peril, you may enjoy this trailer for the book!

Pearson is also a very good writer, and it was easy to sink into her world here and follow along. I’ve only read one other book by her, the regency melodrama The Price of Temptation (also with an awesome original cover), but I felt this one was a stronger story. She’s only written three books (under this name at least), with the last one out in 2010, which is too bad. She’s quite good, and I hope she returns to writing. (Her website has a 2014 status update of working on a new book, so I think that sounds very promising and am looking forward to it.)

RATING: 4 STARS

 

BOOK INFO:

8938290Title: Discreet Young Gentleman
Author: MJ Pearson
Publisher:  Seventh Window Publications
Pages: 194
Release Date:  October 1, 2006
Purchase Links:  Amazon

8 comments on “COVERS WEEK REVIEW: “Discreet Young Gentleman” by MJ Pearson

  1. ilhem3606
    June 23, 2014

    I’m pretty sure tourists would fondle Dean for luck and orgasms. :D

    Like

    • TracyTG
      June 24, 2014

      Heh! And people would wonder why that part of the statue was so shiny and smooth… :D

      Like

  2. Jenni
    June 23, 2014

    I’m sorta partial to the earlier cover myself. ;-)

    Like

    • TracyTG
      June 24, 2014

      It’s hard not to be. It’s actually very well drawn and colored! I like the idea of an artist painting it, and all those muscles, and that bulge! I hope they had a good time while doing so. :-)

      Like

  3. Kaje Harper
    June 23, 2014

    I enjoyed this book (and I much prefer the early cover to Tony – thanks for speaking up for my guy. :) That first cover is so incredibly bad it’s memorable and a conversation piece. The new one is boring and inoffensive. Regency Wolverine meets My Little Pony for the win.

    This is actually quite a decent historical romance, with a set-up straight out of a Harlequin romance, but after that point, it has two likeable MCs and a smooth easy ride with enough emotion to hold my attention. Sweet, amusing, absorbing, and a 4-star read for me too.

    BTW, Tony is a busy guy. Because he’s cute in a relaxed, unforced way, and has scores of different pictures, he shows up a lot. I just spotted him on a dentist’s ad. The downside to stock photo sites. But I can’t regret picking him, because he looks just like Tony should to me.

    Like

    • TracyTG
      June 24, 2014

      I agree–it’s an fun story, and I dig that Pearson was writing m/m regency before the genre really went up a notch in popularity. (I also dig that she or her publisher had the foresight to commission those awesome early covers. They’re so over-the-top, I can’t help but love them.)

      Like

    • TracyTG
      June 24, 2014

      And regarding Tony–he’s always who I picture for the character (which makes seeing him on other covers so weird. “Tony! What are you doing over there? Where’s Mac???”

      Liked by 1 person

      • Kaje Harper
        June 24, 2014

        LOL – I love that :)

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on June 23, 2014 by in Historical, Reviewer: Tracy and tagged , , , .

Follow Us On Twitter

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Archives

%d bloggers like this: