"Boys in Our Books"…

…we're keeping our name but expanding our offerings!

REVIEW: “For a Rainy Afternoon” by R.J. Scott



A Tale of the Curious Cookbook

Robbie MacIntyre manages a small post office in the old Station House on the outskirts of sleepy Barton Hartshourn northwest of London. He’s stunned when the owner, Maggie, a close friend, bequeaths him not only the post office, but also Station House.

The rest of her estate is left to an American writer, Jason Young, and when he moves to the village, Robbie is thrown by the attraction he has for the man who has more of a claim on the Station House than he does.

Then there is a box that holds several rare first editions and a cookbook. Only when the secrets of the ingredients in a particular recipe are finally revealed does everything begin to make sense, and a love cut short seventy years earlier is finally discovered.


This is an enjoyable little novella. I am quite familiar with Ms. Scott’s writing (although I haven’t read any of her stories for a year). It doesn’t mean that I don’t have any discontents, though. I’ll focus on those first.

I thought that Jason as a character wasn’t developed enough. Probably because the story was narrated from Robbie’s perspective and somehow it made me miss who Jason really was. It said that Jason was an author but I didn’t really get to know how successful he was, what kind of books he loved to write. Just the fact that Jason was writing something historical at the moment. Jason was also said to be very rich, that money was not a problem for him, but again, I didn’t get that from the story. There was one summarized paragraph on how Robbie and Jason connected and they talked about EVERYTHING. And all I could do as a reader was … “Say what?!? What is EVERYTHING??

I also felt like I was missing the idea of this series – a tale of the curious cookbook – uhm, is it only because Robbie found that mysterious cookbook of Maggie’s? Will this be the kind of cookbook that is shared by different couples written by different authors? Is there something magical from the cookbook or is it stated as “curious” simply because the recipes there are written for different types of situations? I wish Ms. Scott explored that, especially since this is practically the first story of the series. It would be nice if there was a footing of it somehow. Even if the stories are meant to be stand-alone.

But despite those issues, I still found that there was something comforting in reading about two men in a quiet British village setting. I loved the relationship building – I loved that Robbie (with his red hair!!) always wanted someone who was quiet and could appreciate those rainy afternoons. And Robbie never thought he would find it in an American! Plus this little novella came to me right after I rated a book with 2.5*. So it felt like a wonderful remedy to my heart and soul.

Final though, that lovely cover! Isn’t it a breath of fresh air, not having to stare at naked torsos? Or any facial expressions to be honest? I always love it when the MM romance covers don’t feature any men at all. So this one is just pretty for me and it’s actually the reason why I decided to read the whole series.



ForaRainyAfternoonLGTitle: For a Rainy Afternoon
Author: R.J. Scott
Publisher: Dreamspinner Press
Pages: 66
Release Date: April 1, 2015
Purchase Links: Dreamspinner Press, ARe, Amazon

About Ami

My name is Ami and I'm an Indonesian girl in my mid 30's, living in Jakarta, the capital of Indonesia. I used to do a lot of journal writing in a different website but over the years, I started to lose interest. I am, instead, pretty active in reading and writing opinion in Goodreads. Then I start thinking that maybe I can have a blog in which I write mostly about books or joy of reading or anything related to reading activity, really. So this is what this blog is for ... although, I may be inspired to write off-books topic as well :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on April 1, 2015 by in Contemporary, Reviewer: Ami and tagged , , , , .

Follow Us On Twitter

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.



%d bloggers like this: